АНАЛИЗ ЛИТЕРАТУРЫ ПО ТЕХНОЛОГИЯМ ИЗМЕРЕНИЯ УРОВНЯ ЖИДКИХ ПРОДУКТОВ НА ПРОИЗВОДСТВЕННЫХ ПРЕДПРИЯТИЯХ

Юсупбеков Н. Р. & Буронов Б. А.


Annotatsiya

Точное измерение уровня жидких продуктов в ёмкостях имеет важное значение для устойчивого управления и контроля технологических процессов на производственных предприятиях. Надёжное определение количества жидкости в резервуарах, технологических аппаратах и ёмкостях хранения способствует повышению производственной безопасности, контролю расхода сырья, а также точному учёту готовой продукции. Поэтому на промышленных объектах устройства измерения уровня рассматриваются как неотъемлемая часть технологической системы. В настоящее время для определения уровня жидкости применяются гидростатические методы, методы дифференциального давления, ёмкостные, ультразвуковые, радарные, оптические, радиометрические и другие методы. Данные методы отличаются друг от друга принципом действия, точностью измерения, надёжностью, наличием или отсутствием контакта с измеряемой средой, а также возможностями применения в промышленных условиях. В связи с этим сравнительный анализ методов измерения уровня жидких продуктов, а также оценка их метрологических возможностей и эксплуатационных характеристик представляют собой важную научно-практическую задачу данного направления.


Adabiyotlar

  1. Johnson, C.D. Process Control Instrumentation Technology. — 8th Edition. — England: Pearson Education Limited, 2014. — P. 1–31. — ISBN 978-1-292-02601.
  2. Bo‘ronov Bobirmirzo Alisher o‘g‘li. “Suyuqlik sathini o‘lchash parametrlarining tahlili va zamonaviy usullari” // Academic Research in Modern Science International Scientific-Online Conference. — 2025. — P. 152–157.
  3. Yuriy P. Kondratenko, Oleksiy V. Kozlov, Andriy M. Topalov, Oleksandr S. Gerasin. “Computerized System for Remote Level Control with Discrete Self-Testing” // Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing. — 2017.
  4. Prashant Pandey, Rajan Mishra, R.K. Chauhan. “IoT‐Enabled Liquid Level Measurement and Characterization Using Differential Pressure Sensor Method” // Clean – Soil, Air, Water. — 2025. — Vol. 53, Issue 7. — Wiley.
  5. Nodirbek Rustambekovich Yusupbekov, Azamat Alijonovich Yusupov, Bobir Alisher ogli Boronov. “Improving the Accuracy of Measuring the Volume and Mass of Liquid Product in Horizontal Cylindrical Tanks” // Chemical Technology, Control and Management. — 2021. — Vol. 2021, No. 2 (98). — P. 33–40.
  6. Mateus Rogienfisz, Laura Silva de Assis, Felipe da Rocha Henriques. “Liquid Monitoring System in Industrial Tanks with Ultrasonic Sensor” // Sociedade Brasileira de Telecomunicações Proceedings. — 2017.
  7. Renwang Ge, Di Zhang, Renyuan Tong, Qingwen Li. “Non-contact sealed vessel liquid level measurement and device design based on ultrasonic principle” // International Conference on Modeling, Simulation and Process Control (ICMSP). — 2022. — P. 120–125.
  8. Shenoy R., Kumar A., Nair P. и др. “An In‐Depth Analysis of Liquid Level Measurement Techniques and Performance Evaluation Using Computational Fluid Dynamics” // Journal of Sensors. — 2025. — Wiley.
  9. “Design and Development of Submersible Hydrostatic Level Sensor Using a GMR Sensor” // Measurement. — 2023. — Vol. 206. — Article 112310.
  10. Esmaili P., Cavedo F., Norgia M. “Characterization of Pressure Sensor for Liquid-Level Measurement in Sloshing Condition” // IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement. — 2020. — Vol. 69, No. 7. — P. 4379–4386.
  11. Smith J.O., Montrose R.C., Barth S. Closed tank fill level sensor: patent US20210310848A1, МПК G01F23/14, G01F23/18 / Independent Technologies LLC. — Application No. 17/349551; filed 16.06.2021; published 07.10.2021.
  12. Brackett A.W., Durham M.O., Perkins L.K., Thoman G.E. Tank gauging apparatus and method: patent US5315867A, Int. Cl. G01F23/00 / Emerson Electric Co. — Filed 12.05.1992; patented 31.05.1994. — 12 p.
  13. Takacs G.W. Precise Volume Fluid Dispenser: patent US5568882A, Int. Cl. B67D5/08 / ABC Techcorp. — Appl. No. 08/383,445; filed 03.02.1995; patented 29.10.1996. — 11 p. — P. 1–10.
  14. Gao W., Liu W., Hu Y., Wang J. “Study of Ultrasonic Near-Field Region in Ultrasonic Liquid-Level Monitoring System” // Micromachines. — 2020. — Vol. 11, No. 8. — Article 763.
  15. Mukherjee D., Sen N., Singh K.K., Saha Sh., Mukhopadhyay S., Shenoy K.T., Marathe P.P. “Ultrasonic Method for Online Tracking of Interface and Dispersion Band in Gravity Settlers” // Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research. — 2020.
  16. Abdullayeva D.A., Bozorov E.O., Okhunboboyeva Ch.Z., Abduganiyev A.A., Azizova N.Sh. “Monitoring And Measuring The Level Of Water Objects By the Ultrasonic Method” // Solid State Technology. — 2020. — Vol. 63, Issue 5. — P. 5591–5597.
  17. Escandón-Panchana P., Morante-Carballo F., Herrera-Franco G., Rodríguez H., Carvajal F. “Fluid Level Measurement System in Oil Storage. Python, Lab-Based Scale” // Mathematical Modelling of Engineering Problems. — 2022. — Vol. 9, No. 3. — P. 787–795.
  18. Ambrozinski L., Lisowski M., Stepinski T., Uhl T. “Permanently Installed Guided-waves Based Liquid Level Sensors for Hermetically Sealed Tanks” // 11th European Conference on Non-Destructive Testing (ECNDT). — 2014. — Prague, Czech Republic.
  19. Sánchez-de-le-Lleve D. “Non-Contact Liquid Level Measurement Using the Talbot Effect and Adaptive Photodetectors” // IEEE Instrumentation & Measurement Magazine. — 2024. — Vol. 27. — P. 48–52.
  20. Komatsu Y., Nobeshima T. “Flange-type Liquid-Level Sensor Based on Laser Light Reflection” // Sensors International. — 2023. — Vol. 4. — Article 100230.
  21. Artan M., Soydemir M.U., Şahin S. “ARM Based Hybrid Measurement System Design for Liquid Level Measurement with High Accuracy under Vibrating Case” // European Journal of Science and Technology. — 2020. — Special Issue. — P. 381–388.
  22. Мастепаненко М.А. Информационно-измерительная система непрерывного контроля уровня топлива в емкостях: диссертация кандидата технических наук: 05.11.16 — Информационно-измерительные и управляющие системы / М.А. Мастепаненко. — Ставрополь, 2014. — 223 с. — С. 1–20.
  23. Rodríguez-Montero P., Sánchez-de-le-Lleve D. “Non-Contact Liquid Level Measurement Using the Talbot Effect and Adaptive Photodetectors” // IEEE Instrumentation & Measurement Magazine. — 2024. — Vol. 27. — P. 48–52.
  24. María L. Pelayo-Fernández, José L. Arce-Diego, D. Pereda-Cubián, O. Ormachea, O.G. Romanov, A.L. Tolstik. “Liquid-level Sensor Based in Laser Feedback Interferometry for Oil Tanks Applications” // Proceedings of SPIE. — 2006. — Vol. 6180.
  25. Juan Carlos Martínez Espinosa, Juan de Dios Ortiz Alvarado, Fidel Córdoba Valdes, Marcos Alberto Rodriguez Martinez, Marcos Leonardo Fuentes Avila, Rafael Guzmán Cabrera. “Volume Measurement System Based on Hall Effect Sensors Circularly Coupled and Arranged in a Quadrature Shape” // Computación y Sistemas. — 2021. — Vol. 25, No. 2. — P. 417–422.
  26. “Understanding Magnetostrictive Level Technology Through the Features and Benefits of ABB’s LMT Series”. — ABB technical material.
  27. “Research on magnetostrictive liquid level gauge for water level measurement of steam generator”. — Научная статья, 2024.
  28. Toth Ferencz Nandor. A capacitive sensor for water level measurement in an oil tank: patent EP1072870A1, МПК G01F23/26 / Enraf B.V. (NL). — Application No. 00202580.7; filed 18.07.2000; published 31.01.2001. — 11 p.
  29. Brajesh Kumar, G. Rajita, Nirupama Mandal. “A Review on Capacitive-Type Sensor for Measurement of Height of Liquid Level” // Measurement and Control. — 2014. — Vol. 47, No. 7. — P. 219–224.
  30. M. Neumayer, H. Zangl. “Electrical Capacitance Tomography for Level Measurements of Separated Liquid Stacks” // SENSOR+TEST Conferences 2011 Proceedings. — Graz University of Technology, Austria. — 2011. — P. 433–438.
  31. Yiyang Tian, Jinshui Qiu, Boyun Liu. “Measuring Halon Level Based on the Model of Residual Ultrasonic Waves in Container's Wall” // Proceedings of the 2012 International Conference on Computer Application and System Modeling (ICCASM 2012). — Atlantis Press, 2012. — P. 850–852.
  32. Arunkumar Heddallikar, Raymond Pinto, Avik Bhattacharya, Y.S. Rao, Gulab Singh. “Precision Level Measurement using VNA based Radar Interferometry” // IEEE International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium (IGARSS). — 2023. — P. 1–4.
  33. Baofeng Jia. “Application of the Improved Radar Level Gauge in Level Measurement of Liquid Tanks” // Industrial Instrumentation and Automation Equipment. — 2017.
  34. Dr. S. Venkateswara Rao. “Architectural and Operational Aspects of A U-Shaped Solid Glass Rod Probe Multimode Fiber Optic Analog Liquid Level Sensor” // International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT). — 2017. — Vol. 6, Issue 11. — P. 47–50.
  35. Kouji Suemori, Yuichiro Komatsu, Taiki Nobeshima. “Flange-type Liquid-Level Sensor Based on Laser Light Reflection” // Sensors International. — 2023. — Vol. 4. — Article 100230.
  36. Rodrigo T. Bento, Roger W. O. Silva, Lucas A. Dias, André Ferrus Filho, Antônio J. C. Pitta. “Design, Development and Application of a Real-Time Capacitive Sensor for Automatically Measuring Liquid Level” // SN Applied Sciences. — 2019. — Vol. 1. — P. 734.
  37. Chong-yong Su, Shu-ren Yang. “Application of Optical Fiber Sensing Technology in Oil Tank Level Measurement” // Advances in Engineering Research. — 2017. — Vol. 136. — Atlantis Press, China. — P. 149–152.
  38. Изосин В.А. Дозатор для жидкого реагента: патент RU2023117061A, МПК B01F23/40, E21B37/06 / ООО Торговый Дом «Магнитогорский завод химических реагентов». — Заявка №2023117061; заявл. 19.08.2022; опубл. 19.02.2024. — 2 с.
  39. Atalay Ö., Belli B., Sezgin O. “Improving level measurement techniques and measurement accuracy in vehicle fuel tanks” // International Journal of Automotive Engineering and Technologies. — 2022. — Vol. 11, No. 3. — P. 110–116.
  40. Souza M., Carvalho E., Canuto J., Freire R., Brusamarello V. “Displacer-Type Liquid Level Sensor with Liquid Density Auto-Compensation” // Journal of Integrated Circuits and Systems. — 2020. — Vol. 15, No. 3. — P. 1–5.
  41. Lowe J.W. Liquid Level Sensor: patent US6666085B1, Int. Cl. G01F23/00 / Jerry Watson Lowe. — Appl. No. 10/233,097; filed 28.08.2002; patented 23.12.2003. — 8 p. — P. 1–6.
  42. Калашников А.А. Методы и средства повышения метрологической достоверности контроля уровня в технологических емкостях АЭС: диссертация кандидата технических наук: 05.13.05 — Элементы и устройства вычислительной техники и систем управления / А.А. Калашников. — Москва, 2017. — 161 с. — С. 1–120.
  43. Melchionni D., Norgia M. “Optical system for liquid level measurements” // Review of Scientific Instruments. — 2014. — Vol. 85, No. 7.
  44. Lazaro R.C., Frizera A., Marques C., Leal-Junior A.G. “Optical Fiber Sensors Systems in Oil Tanks: Toward Structural Health Monitoring and Liquid-Level Estimation” // IEEE Sensors Journal. — 2023. — Vol. 23. — P. 10437–10443.
  45. Dejband E., Manie Y.C., Deng Y.-J., Bitew M.A., Tan T.-H., Peng P.-C. “High Accuracy and Cost-Effective Fiber Optic Liquid Level Sensing System Based on Deep Neural Network” // Sensors. — 2023. — Vol. 23, No. 4. — Article 2360.
  46. Guo H., Zhang Y., Li Z. и др. “The liquid level monitoring with sub-millimeter resolution by discrete wavelength sampling method” // Sensors and Actuators A: Physical. — 2018. — Vol. 282. — P. 237–242.
  47. Kim H., Balagopal B., Kerrigan S., Garcia N., Chow M.-Y., Bourham M., Fang T., Jiang X. “Noninvasive Liquid Level Sensing with Laser Generated Ultrasonic Waves” // SSRN Electronic Journal. — 2022. — North Carolina State University, USA.
  48. Yin G., Yang P., Xiao H. и др. “High-Resolution and Large-Sensing-Range Liquid-Level Sensor Based on Optical Frequency Domain Reflectometry and No-Core Fiber” // Sensors. — 2022. — Vol. 22, No. 12. — Article 4480.
  49. “Measuring Fluid Level through a Recalibrating-Free Hough Transform Methodology” // Научная статья, посвящённая бесконтактному определению уровня жидкости на основе компьютерного зрения, преобразования Хафа и методов обработки изображений.
  50. Юсупова Феруза, Нематёнов Ж.С. “ZAMONAVIY MIKROKONTROLLERLAR, ARDUINO VA ULTRATOVUSHLI SATH DATCHIGI YORDAMIDA SUYUQLIK SATHINI O‘LCHASH TIZIMI” // Partner Conferences of the International Scientific Journal Research Focus. — 2025. — Т. 1, № 1. — С. 696–701.
  51. Подчашинський Ю.О., Іщенко О.С. “Використання ультразвукових датчиків для вимірювання рівня та густини рідини в комп’ютеризованих інформаційно-вимірювальних системах” // Tehnìčna ìnženerìâ. — 2025. — № 1 (95). — P. 389–394.
  52. Vellela S.S., Babu B.V., Mahendra D., Bharat Y. “IoT-Based Tank Water Monitoring Systems: Enhancing Efficiency and Sustainability” // International Journal for Modern Trends in Science and Technology. — 2024. — Vol. 10, Issue 02. — P. 291–298.
  53. Iradukunda Y. “Smart Tanks Juice Level Monitoring System: A Case Study of Raha Beverages Company Limited Arusha, Tanzania” // Dissertation. — 2023.
  54. Altin S., Bulut F. “Bluetooth Bağlantılı Ultrasonik Sıvı Seviyesi Ölçer Tasarımı ve Endüstriyel Proses Uygulamaları” // Journal of Engineering and Natural Sciences. — 2016. — Vol. 4, No. 1. — P. 19–21.
  55. Saeed M. “Measurement System to Monitor Interface Level Between Oil and Water in a Rapidly Rotating System” // Master of Science Thesis MMK 2013:16 MDA 447. — KTH Industrial Engineering and Management, Sweden. — 2013.
  56. Liu B., Xiao Y., Wang L., Wang W., Hu J. “A non-reference detection method of the external ultrasonic liquid level switch using the PZT” // Journal of Measurements in Engineering. — 2023. — Vol. 11, Issue 2. — P. 97–110.
  57. Bello M.I., Gana S.M., Faruk M.I., Umar M.J. “Autonomous Ultrasonic Based Water Level Detection and Control System” // Nigerian Journal of Technology (NIJOTECH). — 2018. — Vol. 37, No. 2. — P. 508–513.
  58. Jan F., Min-Allah N., Saeed S., Iqbal S.Z., Ahmed R. “IoT-Based Solutions to Monitor Water Level, Leakage, and Motor Control for Smart Water Tanks” // Water. — 2022. — Vol. 14. — Article 309.
  59. Workneh H., Raptis I.A. “A Comprehensive Experimental Liquid‐Level Control System for Advancing Fault Diagnosis Research Innovation: Data, Models, and Procedures” // Advanced Control for Applications. — 2025. — Vol. 7, Issue 2. — Wiley.
  60. Olejnik P., Awrejcewicz J. “Intelligent Mechatronics in the Measurement, Identification, and Control of Water Level Systems: A Review and Experiment” // Обзорная научная статья, посвящённая сравнительному анализу ультразвуковых, ёмкостных, оптических и гидростатических датчиков в системах измерения, идентификации и управления уровнем воды.
  61. Newton G.F., Aondona T.I., Chile C.A. “Design and Implementation of a Wireless Fluid Level Display System Using Ultrasonic Sensing Technique” // Journal of Engineering Research and Reports. — 2020. — Vol. 14, No. 1. — P. 30–40.
  62. Deng H., Chen H. “RadarEye: Robust Liquid Level Tracking Using mmWave Radar in Robotic Pouring” // arXiv preprint. — 2026. — arXiv:2602.10417.
  63. Heddallikar A., Pinto R., Bhattacharya A., Rao Y.S., Singh G. “Precision Level Measurement using VNA based Radar Interferometry” // IEEE International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium (IGARSS). — 2023. — P. 1–4.
  64. Jia B. “Application of the Improved Radar Level Gauge in Level Measurement of Liquid Tanks” // Industrial Instrumentation and Automation Equipment. — 2017.
  65. Fusco L., Grassini S., Corbellini S., Parvis M. “Extending Industrial Applicability of TDR Liquid Level Monitoring through Flexible Probes” // IEEE International Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference (I2MTC). — 2013. — IEEE, USA.
  66. Jia B. “Application of the Improved Radar Level Gauge in Level Measurement of Liquid Tanks” // Automation Application. — 2017.
  67. Nagy L. “Microstrip Antenna Development for Radar Sensor” // Sensors. — 2023. — Vol. 23. — Article 909. — MDPI, Switzerland.
  68. Nagle R.K., Hines J.B., Kurfess T.R. “Guided Wave Tank Level Sensor” // IEEE Conference Publication. — 2019. — IEEE, USA.
  69. Ma Y., Zhang Z., Fang Y. и др. “Design of 120 GHz FMCW Radar Liquid Level Measurement System” // IEEE Conference Publication. — 2023. — IEEE, USA.
  70. Deng Zhi-guang, Zhu Bi-wei, Wu Qian, Wang Xue-mei, Xu Si-jie, Zhu Jia-liang, Dong Chen-long, Sun Yong-sheng. “Research on Application of High Temperature and High Pressure Radar Liquid Level Measurement in Nuclear Power Plant” // New Energy Power Generation Automation and Intelligent Technology. — Singapore: Springer, 2023. — P. 57–72.
  71. Ehrentraut H., Jäger M., Dötzer W. “Silo and Tank Vision: Applications, Challenges, and Technical Solutions for Radar Measurement of Liquids and Bulk Solids in Tanks and Silos” // IEEE Instrumentation & Measurement Magazine. — 2017. — Vol. 20, No. 4. — P. 18–27.
  72. Grose D. Tanker truck fluid level measurement systems and methods: patent US20210255020A1, МПК G01F22/00, G01F23/284, B67D7/22 / Dean Grose. — Application No. 17/024,673; filed 17.09.2020; published 19.08.2021. — 13 p.
  73. Turner J. Tank Multi-Level Measurement Using Threaded Pie and Millimeter Wave Radar: patent US11555732B2, Int. Cl. G01F23/284, G01S13/08 / Laser Tech LLC. — Appl. No. 16/829,019; filed 25.03.2020; patented 17.01.2023. — 23 p.
  74. Baker G.W., Jiang T., Luna J.A., Flower M., Naccarato L.R., Bowen M.D. Device, System and Method for Guided Wave Radar Measurement: patent US20230077375A1, Int. Cl. G01F23/282 / Rochester Sensors, LLC. — Appl. No. 17/873,059; filed 25.07.2022; published 16.03.2023. — 20 p.
  75. Bergeron C.G., Lawrence R.R., Clark J.J., Hite D.R. Redundant Level Measuring System: patent US11391616B2, Int. Cl. G01F23/30, G01F23/296, G01F25/20 / Magnetrol International, Incorporated. — Appl. No. 16/999,333; filed 21.08.2020; patented 19.07.2022. — 12 p.
  76. Wegner T.E., Gebhardt S., Del Galdo G. “Fill level measurement of low-permittivity material using an M-sequence UWB radar” // International Journal of Microwave and Wireless Technologies. — 2023. — Vol. 15. — P. 1–9.
  77. Yahya S.I. “A Multi-Level Storage Tank Gauging And Monitoring System Using A Nanosecond Pulse” // International Journal of Engineering Trends and Technology (IJETT). — 2013. — Vol. 5, No. 1. — P. 17–24.
  78. Van Der Pol R. Distance measuring device especially for measuring the fill level in industrial tanks: patent EP0458678A1, Int. Cl. G01F23/28. — Published 27.11.1991. — 9 p.
  79. Юсупбеков Н.Р., Юсупов А.А. “Review and Comparative Analysis of Modern Devices For Level Gauging In Checking System And Industrial Processing Control” // International Journal of Advanced Science and Technology. — 2020. — Vol. 29, No. 9s. — P. 5370–5380.
  80. Restivo F., Silva T., Santos B., Lopes G. “Water level sensing: State of the art review and performance evaluation of a low-cost measurement system” // Measurement. — 2016. — Vol. 89. — P. 204–214.
  81. Shenoy R., Kumar A., Nair P. и др. “An In‐Depth Analysis of Liquid Level Measurement Techniques and Performance Evaluation Using Computational Fluid Dynamics” // Journal of Sensors. — 2025. — Wiley, USA.
  82. Dunn W.C. Fundamentals of Industrial Instrumentation and Process Control. — New York: McGraw-Hill, 2005. — 337 p. — ISBN 0-07-145735-6. — P. 1–27, 85–97, 201–216.
  83. Primo J. Instrumentation & Process Control Automation Guidebook – Part 3. — PDH Online Course E444. — Fairfax: PDH Online, 2020. — 91 p. — P. 1–27.
  84. Level measurement [Electronic resource]. — Available at: http://www.kipinfo.ru.
  85. Questions on the level gauges [Electronic resource]. — Available at: http://www.rospribor.com.
  86. Technical library [Electronic resource]. — Available at: http://lib.qrz.ru/book.
  87. Zhdankin V.K. Level measurement by directional electromagnetic radiation. — Moscow, 2004.